12 Best Picture Oscar Nominees Deserve to Win

Which Best Picture Oscar Nominees Truly Deserve to Win?

Trying to predict the Oscars can feel like a guessing game. This article breaks down the best picture Oscar nominees deserve to win based on critical reviews, audience reception, and unique storytelling.

Discover the standout films that deserve the ultimate accolade.

1. The Power of the Dog: Unraveling Complex Characters

Welcome to Greenlight Coverage! Here, we explore why “The Power of the Dog” is a strong contender for the best picture. Use code 5OFFNOW at checkout to get 5% off our services at Greenlight Coverage.

The Power of the Dog masterfully intertwines character complexities with unique storytelling. The plot centers around Phil Burbank, a wealthy rancher whose dark and enigmatic personality stands out. As you follow his interactions with other characters, you can see the intricate layers peeling back to reveal deeper motivations.

• Character Depth: Phil Burbank’s character exhibits a multifaceted personality. This adds a rich texture to the storyline. His evolving relationship with other characters, such as young Peter, holds the audience’s attention.
• Narrative Techniques: The film uses subtle narrative elements to flesh out character backstories and motivations. Each character’s journey feels organic, keeping you engaged from start to finish.
• Stellar Performances: The acting elevates the screenplay. Performances are intense and believable, compelling viewers to connect emotionally.

In summary, The Power of the Dog excels in character-driven storytelling, making it a noteworthy best picture nominee.

2. Dune: Outstanding World-Building and Visual Mastery

Dune is a visual spectacle that redefines cinematic standards. Directed by Denis Villeneuve, this adaptation of Frank Herbert’s novel transports you to the immersive universe of Arrakis.

• Seamless World-Building: The film excels at creating a rich, detailed world that feels real. The production design is highlighted as “off the charts,” showcasing a distinct style and culture for the various houses and peoples represented in the film.
• Visual Excellence: The integration of CGI and live-action scenes sets new standards. From vast desert landscapes to intricate cityscapes, every frame is a visual treat.
• Storytelling Through Visuals: The visual elements are not mere eye-candy; they play a critical role in narrative development. For instance, the harshness of Arrakis’ environment mirrors the story’s intense struggles and political drama.

By providing an experience that is immersive and visually stunning, Dune makes a strong case for why it deserves to be crowned best picture.

3. Belfast: A Touching Semi-Autobiographical Narrative

Belfast excels at delivering an emotional, semi-autobiographical narrative. Directed by Kenneth Branagh, this film is a heartfelt portrayal of his childhood during the tumultuous period in Northern Ireland.

• Emotional Resonance: The storyline captures the innocence of childhood amidst political unrest. This creates a poignant contrast that tugs at your heartstrings.
• Authentic Representation: Branagh’s direction ensures authenticity in the storytelling. From the setting to the dialect, everything feels true to the time and place.
• Personal Touch: The autobiographical elements add a layer of intimacy, making you feel more connected to the narrative. The characters are not just figures in the story, but representations of real people who faced genuine struggles.

Belfast stands out due to its emotional depth and authentic narrative, making it a worthy nominee for best picture.

4. King Richard: A Heartfelt Biographical Triumph

King Richard tells the inspiring true story of Richard Williams, the determined father behind tennis champions Venus and Serena Williams. This biopic effectively captures the essence of perseverance and family.

• Inspirational Narrative: The story of Richard Williams is one of grit and determination. His unyielding focus on his daughters’ success is both inspiring and heartwarming.
• Character Dynamics: The relationship dynamics are handled with care. Richard’s relationship with his daughters is central, portraying both the challenges and triumphs they face together.
• Performances: The actors embody their roles with authenticity. The portrayal of Richard by Will Smith, in particular, is both powerful and relatable.

With its compelling narrative and heartfelt performances, King Richard definitely earns its spot as a best picture nominee.

5. Licorice Pizza: A Nostalgic Coming-of-Age Tale

Licorice Pizza captures the essence of youth and romance with a touch of nostalgia. This coming-of-age story takes you on a journey through the adventures and misadventures of young love in the 1970s.

• Nostalgic Elements: The film beautifully recreates the atmosphere of the 1970s. From the music to the fashion, every detail adds to the nostalgic feel.
• Relatable Narrative: The characters’ journey of self-discovery and romance is universally relatable. It taps into the universal themes of growth and exploration.
• Compelling Storytelling: The film uses humor and emotion expertly, making the narrative engaging and heartfelt. The characters of Gary Valentine and Alana Kane are portrayed with compelling depth and complexity](https://www.midlandsmovies.com/review-of-licorice-pizza).

By offering a nostalgic trip back in time, Licorice Pizza wins over audiences and justifies its nomination for best picture.

6. West Side Story: A Modern Take on a Classic

Steven Spielberg’s adaptation of West Side Story breathes new life into the classic musical. This modern take maintains the essence of the original while addressing contemporary issues.

• Modern Adaptation Techniques: Spielberg’s direction brings a modern sensibility to the film. The choreography and set design are both innovative and respectful of the original.
• Contemporary Resonance: The narrative tackles issues that are still relevant today. Themes of love, violence, and racial tension are portrayed with a fresh perspective.
• Stunning Performances: The cast delivers performances that honor the original while adding their unique flair. The chemistry between the lead characters is palpable, further enhancing the story.

West Side Story proves that a classic can be made new again, making it deserving of its best picture nomination.

7. Nightmare Alley: Brilliant Noir Storytelling

Nightmare Alley stands out as a compelling example of noir storytelling. Directed by Guillermo del Toro, this film masterfully blends dark psychological elements with an intriguing plot.

• Noir Elements: The film stays true to the noir genre, featuring morally complex characters and a dark, brooding atmosphere.
• Intriguing Plot: The storyline keeps you on edge with its unpredictable twists and turns. It delves into the darker aspects of human nature.
• Artistic Direction: Guillermo del Toro’s direction and visual style add a unique touch, making every scene visually engaging.

With its brilliant noir storytelling and artistic direction, Nightmare Alley earns its place among the best picture nominees.

8. CODA: An Empowering Family Drama

CODA is an empowering drama that skillfully handles themes of deaf culture and family dynamics. It revolves around Ruby Rossi, a Child of Deaf Adults (CODA), and her unique journey.

• Representation of Deaf Culture: The film authentically portrays the experience of a deaf family. It captures the nuances and challenges while celebrating their culture.
• Family Dynamics: The narrative explores the complex dynamics of a family where one member is hearing. Ruby’s struggle to balance her dreams and family responsibilities adds depth to the story.
• Inspiring Message: At its core, CODA conveys an inspiring message about following your dreams and embracing your identity.

CODA excels in its representation and storytelling, making it a strong contender for best picture.

9. Drive My Car: Intricacy in Narrative and Emotion

“Drive My Car” offers a profoundly intricate narrative that combines subtle emotional layers with striking character development. This film, directed by Ryusuke Hamaguchi, is adapted from Haruki Murakami’s short story, and it beautifully translates the complexity of the source material into a cinematic format.

• Emotional Narrative: The film explores grief, love, and human connections in a nuanced manner. The protagonist, Yusuke Kafuku, drives his red Saab as he attempts to reconcile with his past.
• Character Development: Yusuke’s journey is mirrored by his interactions with others, particularly his driver Misaki. The character arcs feel deeply authentic and relatable.
• Cinematic Techniques: Through long takes and deliberate pacing, Hamaguchi crafts a reflective space for the audience to immerse in the characters’ emotional world. This connection between grief and artistic expression is a testament to the film’s depth](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive_My_Car_(film)).

This film’s ability to weave a complex emotional tapestry ensures its place among the top best picture nominees.

10. Don’t Look Up: A Satirical Commentary on Society

“Don’t Look Up” masterfully uses satire to address urgent global issues, making it a standout among Oscar contenders. Directed by Adam McKay, the film employs humor and sharp wit to deliver its message.

• Satirical Approach: It tackles the topic of climate change and societal apathy in a comedic yet thought-provoking way.
• Relatable Characters: The cast brings the story to life with performances that balance absurdity and real-world relevance.
• Engaging Storytelling: The film’s plot revolves around two astronomers who discover a comet heading towards Earth and try to warn humanity. It’s a wild ride filled with twists and turns that keep viewers on their toes. The film emphasizes the systemic barriers that prevent action](https://www.currentaffairs.org/news/2021/12/critics-of-dont-look-up-are-missing-the-entire-point).

Through its clever satire, “Don’t Look Up” not only entertains but sparks meaningful conversation, earning its nomination.

11. The Tragedy of Macbeth: Innovative Shakespearean Adaptation

Joel Coen’s “The Tragedy of Macbeth” reinvents Shakespeare’s classic for a modern audience. This adaptation stands out due to its innovative approach while remaining faithful to the original text.

• Modern Visual Style: The film’s black-and-white cinematography adds a dramatic flair, enhancing the atmospheric tension.
• Faithful Adaptation: Coen manages to keep the essence of Shakespeare’s work intact while modernizing certain elements for contemporary viewers.
• Powerful Performances: Denzel Washington and Frances McDormand deliver compelling interpretations of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth, imbuing their roles with depth and intensity.

The adaptation’s fresh perspective and powerful execution ensure “The Tragedy of Macbeth” is worthy of its nomination.

12. Tick, Tick…Boom!: A Raw and Personal Musical Journey

“Tick, Tick…Boom!” directed by Lin-Manuel Miranda, offers a deeply personal and raw depiction of Jonathan Larson’s life before his success with “Rent.”

• Personal Narrative: The film is a semi-autobiographical account of Larson’s struggles as a composer. It’s heartfelt and relatable, especially for anyone chasing their dreams.
• Authentic Direction: Miranda captures the spirit of Larson’s work with authenticity and care, weaving musical elements seamlessly into the narrative.
• Impactful Storytelling: The story highlights the difficulties and triumphs Larson faced, offering an inspiring look at perseverance and passion.

Through its raw and personal portrayal, “Tick, Tick…Boom!” resonates deeply, justifying its place as a best picture nominee.

Behind the Screenplay: The Art of Adaptation

Adaptation is an art form that bridges the gap between original works and cinematic storytelling. This year’s nominees demonstrate exceptional craftsmanship in this area.

• Faithfulness to Source Material: Films like “The Power of the Dog” and “Dune” stay true to their literary origins while making thoughtful modifications for cinematic audiences.
• Creative Interpretation: “The Tragedy of Macbeth” showcases how a classic text can be reimagined with a modern artistic vision.
• Emotional Authenticity: Movies such as “Drive My Car” manage to preserve the emotional depth of the original work, resonating with viewers on multiple levels.

Adaptation shines through these films, exemplifying why they are formidable best picture contenders.

Visual Storytelling: Cinematography That Elevates the Narrative

Cinematography often becomes the unsung hero of a film, elevating the narrative to unforgettable heights. This year’s best picture nominees showcase stunning visual storytelling.

• Remarkable Visuals in “Dune”: The detailed world-building and expansive desert landscapes are a visual feast, greatly contributing to the film’s immersive quality.
• Atmospheric Shot Composition: “The Tragedy of Macbeth” uses stark black-and-white imagery to create dramatic tension, enhancing the Shakespearean dialogue.
• Emotive Scenery in “The Power of the Dog”: The sweeping vistas mirror the internal struggles of the characters, adding another layer to the narrative.

The exceptional cinematography in these films ensures visual engagement that complements the storyline.

Scoring a Win: Music’s Role in Enhancing Storytelling

Music and score play a pivotal role in adding emotion and drama to a film. The best picture nominees use their soundtracks to significantly amplify their narratives.

• Epic Soundscapes in “Dune”: Hans Zimmer’s score provides a lush auditory backdrop that heightens the film’s grandeur and intensity.
• Jazz Influence in “Tick, Tick…Boom!”: The music beautifully represents Jonathan Larson’s creative journey and struggles.
• Emotional Resonance in “CODA”: The music in CODA enhances the emotional weight, particularly in scenes focusing on Ruby’s singing aspirations](https://madeleinelovesmovies.com/2021/09/).

The strategic use of music and score in these films helps to elevate the storytelling to new emotional heights.

Conclusion: Who Truly Deserves to Win?

While each nominee brings something unique to the table, the ultimate decision lies in how they resonate with both the audience and critics. Which film do you think should take home the best picture Oscar? Share your thoughts with us!